Friday, September 3, 2010

Quetta Attack: The Responsibility Of Jundullah, Afghanistan And The Organizers - Was Quetta Rally Necessary?



A suicide attacker targeted the Al-Quds rally today in Quetta, the capital of Pakistan's Balochistan province. Fifty Pakistanis are dead and the figure could rise in the next few hours because the injured are in excess of 100.

It is highly irresponsible on the part of the organizers of the rally -- and the government officials that gave it the green signal -- to endanger the lives of Pakistani citizens only two days after twin attacks that targeted public events. In pure security terms, this is a serious lack of judgment on the part of the organizers. The Pakistani government must proceed with criminal charges against the organizers who, in their callousness, put politics before the lives of our citizens at a time when we face foreign-backed terror. The relevant government officials who licensed the procession should be questioned about the sources of their assessment that it was safe to hold huge rallies in these times.

This Al-Quds Day rally was organized by Pakistani Shia organizations that support Iran's call for Al-Quds Day to be held on the last Friday of Ramadan. But by no means is this a Shia religious event. A majority of Pakistanis support al-Quds Day, regardless of religious affiliations. I personally fully support Tehran's courageous stance on Al-Quds, the holy city under Israeli occupation. It's also important to remember that the Al-Quds Day is a political event launched by the government of Iran. It is not a religious event.

Inside Pakistan, the organizers of the rally should have put the safety and security of Pakistani citizens ahead of everything else. A smaller, symbolic public event could have been arranged instead of a large one. The crime of the organizers is especially compounded by the knowledge of what happened in Karachi and Lahore two days earlier.

Unfortunately, Saudi- and Iranian-backed proxy sectarian groups have endangered the lives of Pakistanis for years and put foreign interests before Pakistani national interests. These groups must and should be banned.

It is also important to avoid playing into the hands of the terrorists who did this. Everyone knows we have sectarian groups in the country. But is every attack on one group the work of the opposite group?

Not necessarily.

In other words, Pakistan’s indigenous sectarian groups have been weakened over the years and their foreign support, from Saudi Arabia, Iran or elsewhere, has been considerably curtailed. What is happening is that their remnants are being reorganized by someone else on the Afghan border, arming them and financing them and providing them a new safe haven.

So there is a bigger chance of the recent attacks being the work of the terror-export enterprise that hides in Afghanistan and has been targeting Pakistan since 2005. The first evidence of this is the fact that the attacks have been claimed by a terror group based on the Afghan border.

With an attack on a minority worship place of the Ahmedis earlier in the day in Mardan preceding the Quetta attack by a few hours, it is clear this is not a sectarian issue but an organized campaign by Pakistan's regional enemies. And surely they will find supporters inside Pakistan. Apart from the existing sectarian groups, it is easy to recruit and brainwash poor young Pakistani teenagers, convince them to wear explosive belts and blow themselves up anywhere.

And it's not just Pakistan. Iran has seen attacks on Shia mosques by elements claiming to be Sunnis. But there are no Sunni sectarian groups in Iran. The terrorists who have been attacking Iranian targets are based in US-controlled Afghanistan claiming to represent Sunnis. The attacks in Quetta today and in Karachi and Lahore on Wednesday share the same origin as the attacks in Iran: they are masterminded by terrorists who hide on the border with Afghanistan and have links to foreign intelligence agencies based there. We know that Indians have shown a lot of interest in these groups and established contacts with elements linked to them.

Let us also remember there are external powers in our neighborhood that have an interest in perpetuating chaos in the region. We’ve seen how uneasy United States officials and commentators became when the whole focus in Pakistan turned to the floods and the humanitarian disaster and no one was talking about Washington’s terror war. That’s when at least one US media outlet spun into action and contacted terror ‘spokespersons’ on the Afghan border and solicited statements that can best be described as spreading panic during a national emergency.

It is important that non-religious and non-essential public events in Pakistan -- political and religious -- be curtailed under these circumstances, regardless of sect and politics. If the government and the army can call off parades on days of national significance, including our Independence Day, then unnecessary public congregations can be curtailed as well.

Patriotic Pakistanis, Shias and Sunnis, must step forward and show courage in telling our emotional religious figures that saving the lives of Pakistanis is more important for the time being, especially when none of these public events and processions have any religious sanction.

Pakistani religious figures that refuse to do this and hide behind weak religious pretexts must be charged with endangering the lives of Pakistani citizens.


3 comments:

  1. Ahmed! I respect your intent however there is no point in blaming the rally organizers for these killings.
    Al-Quds rallies have been arranged by Shia organizations for the last 15+ years. Several prominent Sunni figures have also started joining these rallies. The routes of ALL such rallies are pre-approved, pre-planned and pre-announced by the related governments.
    Now if such events are abandoned due to suicide blasts, then tomorrow we will have to stop Rabi ul Awwal celebrations, Muharram processions as well as Juma or any other religous congregation/s.
    Yes there is no sectarian conflict, of this extent, in the country however it is a very known and proven fact that there are certain sectarian outfits in our country that openly call rival sect/s as kafirs. Their mosques, literature, websites and loud speakers are the hate-spreaders that ultimately lead to the emergence of suicide phenomenon. Please note that these outfits are not an outcome of 9/11 at all. They have been working in our country since Zia era.
    Our Government in 1st place and then our Ulema are to be blamed for any such killings other than the ultimate satan i.e US-UK-Israel-India alliance.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sohail,

    1. Large scale processions in the current circumstances are sitting ducks for terrorists. These cannot be condoned. There are many examples of other countries taking similar measures.

    2. The comparison between nonessential processions and between public events such as Friday prayers is illogical. Once again, political processions including the al Quds Day one and other ones by political and religious parties are disorganized, spread over a large geographic area and prone to accidents and terror attacks.

    3. Saving lives is more important than proving anything else. These mesures should be put in place until security officials can testify it is safe to hold public events.

    4. There is no harm in curtailing all of these events and limiting them to pre-designated public places.

    5. This could also be a good omen for the future, when all public events and rallies, political or religious, could be confined to predesignated grounds or confined spaces in order not to disturb the general public.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi. sorry for the delayed response. you are among the intellectuals and people, including myself, do take your points very seriously so i found it imperative to make my points clearer;

    1. large scale processions and gatherings can be and have been condoned successfully. Just 2 of the several examples are annual congregations of Jamaat ud Dawah and Jamat e Islami at Mureedke and Mansoora respectively that are much bigger than any rally and continue for more than 2-3 days. still no problem there
    2. my point was that if we stop not-so-essential gatherings today, tomorrow same will go for essential ones like Friday prayers
    3. lives must be saved BUT by proper security planning and execution NOT by abandoning the activities. You very well know that creating fear among masses is the prime objective of the international and local terrorists. We will serve their purpose by sitting at homes
    4. this rally and all other pre-approved and pre-planned events are confined to specific routes and places. it means that problem is lack of seriousness and/or professionalism from the administration
    5. i agree with you on this point. general public must not be disturbed by any means due to any religious and political gathering.
    we need to curtail the number of such activities as well but Al-Quds day is to show our solidarity for the most oppressed people of the world as more important that several so-called important events

    ReplyDelete

Your comments are welcome. Please do observe common courtesy rules. This blog is linked to PakNationalists.com and follows the same comment guidelines. The purpose of this blog is to promote the views of PakNationalists on Pakistan's domestic and foreign policy interests.