Sunday, October 24, 2010

Sorry, India, You Can't Be A Superpower With A Brain Of A Mouse




India is a big country with the brain of a mouse. Take this headline from India’s largest newspaper, Times of India: Obama Mission: Billions To Pakistan, Billions To India.

I love the headline. It’s not wrong but a little exaggerated. US President Obama is offering $2 billion’s worth of military hardware purchases to Pakistan, subsidized by US government.

For Pakistan, it’s a cautious welcome. Nothing will come to us immediately. The purchases are divided over the next five years. It will be a slow process, involving government red tape, politics and the usual arm-twisting that Washington is so good at. It’s also a lollypop that the US government has dangled before the Pakistani military to calm some of the anger over a US helicopter killing three Pakistani soldiers three weeks ago.

The Indian government knows all this. It also knows that recent US sale of F-16s to Pakistan came with a harsh condition: the planes will be accompanied by US ‘minders’ as part of support staff who will live on the base and ensure Pakistan does not ‘misuse’ the planes, as in against India.

Still, two weeks before Obama lands in India on an official visit, Indian media managers leaked this fabulously-titled but well-researched report, grumbling that billions of Indian dollars will be going to US pockets while Pakistan will be getting billions’ worth of weapons for free. Of course, even if Pakistan buys up all the $2 billion’s worth of US weapons immediately and not over five years, it will still not match India’s massive weapons shopping spree worth $30 billion, to be spent by 2012, meaning within the next two years.

This tells you one thing: the Indian government is really not worried about the puny $2 billion offer to Pakistan tipping the scales. We can’t match India’s $30 billion.

If that is clear, then what is it that India is worried about? Why whine about two billions to Pakistan over five years when India is spending fifteen times that figure in less than two years?

It’s just India’s small-minded pursuit of anything that would undermine Pakistan. There is no way Pakistan would ever invade or destroy India, nor are most Pakistanis interested in this proposition. It’s always the bigger countries that destroy smaller ones. Yet India doesn’t really miss a second seizing any opportunity to hurt Pakistan. Remember 1971 when peaceful Pakistanis were busy in post-elections noise? India launched an unprovoked invasion of Pakistan and, as the invasion unfolded, we discovered the Indians had actually planned it for two years and created and recruited a proxy army inside our country to help them once the invasion started.

The mindset behind the Times of India story is the same mindset that invaded us in 1971, the same mindset that refuses to resolve Kashmir and pave the way for peace, the same mindset that exploits Afghan mess to set up training camps to export terrorists to Pakistan, the same mindset that plants terrorism in Balochistan, and the same mindset that bans Pakistani TV channels across India.

And to confirm the height of this Indian small-mindedness, it is the same mindset that bans Pakistani visitors from posting comments on Indian news websites, no matter how respectful that comment is, if the comment questions official Indian positions on any question. [Let me also add that Pakistani guest columnists are banned in mainstream Indian newspapers for the same reason. Compare that to Pakistani generosity as our newspapers permit guest Indian columnists to write freely even if they criticize official Pakistani policies, and no Pakistani news website bans Indians surfers from posting comments.]

Our American friends can’t see this Indian small-mindedness, of course. That’s why we hear US officials insisting India is not a threat to Pakistan, the latest such gratuitous advice came just this week during the Pak-US strategic dialogue currently underway in Washington.

For Pakistan and India to live in peace, even resolving Kashmir won’t help if India doesn’t get itself a new mindset, big and confident, in contrast to the existing insecure, small-minded way of looking at its smaller neighbors.

NOTE: Not a single Indian visitor to Pakistan, whether a private citizen, government officer or an Indian artist, was ever harassed by Pakistanis in any way in the entire history of Pak-Indian relations. The legendary Pakistani hospitality always embraced and touched visiting Indians as is the case with other foreigners visiting Pakistan.

In comparison, Pakistanis are regularly harassed and intimidated and in some cases even physically attacked while visiting India.

The biggest example is how 60 Pakistanis were burned alive aboard the so-called Samjhota (Friendship) Express train when they believed calls for peace and headed to India in February 2007. Today, the Indian government has admitted Hindu terrorists, including two serving Indian military officers, were behind the gruesome murder. The Indian government, backed by American and British media, insisted immediately after the attacks that they were the work of Pakistan's ISI and Kashmiri freedom groups.

There are more recent examples. Here are two of them to prove this point:

- Bigg Boss planning to send back Pakistani Artists : Pakistani participants in an Indian TV show face life threats by Hindu terrorists. The Indian government and people are unable to protect them.

- Pakistani artist beaten up in Mumbai: A well known Pakistani comedian Shakeel Siddiqui has been tortured by some extremists in Mumbai and ordered to urgently depart from India.

There is a mindset in India, in powerful circles in government, the military and the Hindu terror groups, that can't live with a smaller western neighbor that poses no existential threat to India.

This record of anti-Pakistanism in India contradicts the ridiculous statements of US officials and think-tank types who lecture Pakistan that India is not a threat.


2 comments:

  1. sir there's a correction,the article was named..billions from india,n billions to pakistan!!
    regarding indo-pak war of 1971:India never attacked the eastern front,during the 1965 war,n small skirmishes dat had taken place even before dat!!i dnt deny India was supporting the pro-freedom Mukti Morcha..guerrilla group.i..as ur govt. has been supportin Kashmiries in recent times,n not only wid arms n money bt also wid Man power by lettin its own citizen Die the dogs death,by joinin dese terrorist outfit!!!
    regardin warm welcomes....i think half of ur music related artists r gettin their Rozi roti from India only,i regret dat one particular incident dat u mentioned..!!otherwise we always has been havin warm hearted feelin,dat was on show whn Indian crowd cheered for pakistan's contingent participatin for common wealth!!!i think even ur media had given it a gud coverage!!!n regardin money....when half of pakistan was in flood,we hav came handful by providin 25 million dollars!!!in relief fund setup ed by UN to support pakistani govt.!!n wat we get in return is d hostile attitude,which was on show durin 26/11 mumbai attack!!ur govt. also knows dat Zakiur Rehman Lakhvi was d mastermind!!!bt stil no action is been taken!!!nwz ....india,no longer considers Pakistan a threat!!!Regardin India's Spendin on ARMS,n other battle equipment India is buyin is no more for pakistan but to protect itself from Chinese military Might!!which has become very aggresive dese days,n even by usin 30billion dollars,India is stil usin just 2% of its total GDP,n as per estimate pakitan's govt. spents nearly 20% of pakistans GDP on its Military!!nwz change ur india centric approach n help ur country...to attain a higher heights which it is capable of!!
    Economically ,India-Pak partnership can do wonders for dis SAARC region!!!but our decades old mind set is denying d region dis opportunity !!
    Jai HIND!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is an another attempt at misrepresentation and misinterpretation of facts for one's own benefit by creating sensationalism in Pakistan and to add fuel to the anti-India sentiment.

    1) I completely trash the title of your blog and also the figure that you have put on top. It definitely is a good attempt at humour but with an article of this sentiment, it definitely is forgettable. Whether India becomes a super power or not, it is none of your concern nor it should matter people in Pakistan. They ought to concentrate on how to make Pakistan a superpower. Your statements are not only childish and immature but far from truth and reality; the leading economists and economic agencies world over think that coming times belong to China, India and other growing economies like Russia & Brazil. With your thoughts you claim to have a deeper insight of economics and policy than the cumulative knowledge of all these intellectuals and agencies. As far as brain of the mouse is concerned, we need not tell you the collective brain pool that India has and which is acknowledged and appreciated world over.

    2) As my friend TopguN above has stated India is spending 30 billion dollars on arms and it shouldn't come as a surprise to you and to Pakistan as India too like other sovereign nations has a right for the upgradation of their conventional weapons. And secondly India any day spends lesser amount (% of GDP) than Pakistan. (courtesy World Bank data for the the last 20 years). You endorse Pakistan's spending on JF-17s from China but at the same time object to India's buying weapons from its ally nations.

    3)India's growing relationship with US seems to hurt you a lot. Pakistan's long term ally, how come they be friends with ally?? Isn't it? Ironically, my so called small Indian mind tells me that Pak-US relationship was just about Weapons and Defence it did not go beyond that. You depended on US Dollars and still depend on that, yet you won't leave a chance to abuse US. What a pity!

    4) Samjhauta Express indeed is a blackmark on India's secular fabric and every true India condones the same. You can't judge a nation on the basis of the actions of a handful. Secondly, if that's the case, you ought to look at yourself as a nation. You backstabbed us with Kargil, you funded terror in Kashmir & Punjab. What about that? Before you point fingers at us, you have to come clean of your own wrong doings.

    And stop making wild and irrational statements like "In comparison, Pakistanis are regularly harassed and intimidated and in some cases even physically attacked while visiting India." This is such a preposterous statement to make.

    I know this comment of mine will either be not published on your blog or it will fall on deaf ears.

    ReplyDelete

Your comments are welcome. Please do observe common courtesy rules. This blog is linked to PakNationalists.com and follows the same comment guidelines. The purpose of this blog is to promote the views of PakNationalists on Pakistan's domestic and foreign policy interests.