THIS IMAGE IS PUBLISHED AT A US-BASED WEBSITE
THE LINE IN RED MIGHT BE DOCTORED, ACCORDING TO MANY.
BUT IT IS POSTED ON A US NEWS WEBSITE AND THE RACIAL PROFILING IS ALSO CLEAR.
Pakistan's political and military officials can dodge reality all they want, but no other country in the world has demonized Pakistan and Pakistanis in the last eight years like the United States government and its foreign policy and militay-intelligence communities have done, from spreading false global panic over Pakistan's strategic weapons to sponsoring political and academic events in Washington hosting speakers from little known separatist groups that advocate the break up of Pakistan along linguistic lines.
Now we have pictures such as the one above that are circulating on US websites, targeting Pakistanis despite the fact that it was a US citizen who allegedly freely traveled to meet terrorists right under the eyes and noses of CIA and FBI and their DynCorp and Xe/Blackwater agents who scour Pakistani border regions disguised as ethnic Pakistani Pashtuns. Faisal Shahzad, whose lousy terror attempt raises serious question marks about the conduct of US intelligence community, managed to allegedly travel to the Afghan border region several times and escape racial profiling and dodge every precautionary US anti-terror measure to pull off the Mickey-Mouse-clock-and-firecracker 'car bomb' stint, and yet the responsibility for his action lies on Pakistan, as per Mrs. Clinton, the White House, and now the New York City government.
While demonizing Pakistan, Washington is also guilty of empowering India during those eight years and turning Afghan soil into a launchpad for the export of terrorism into Pakistan.
The American people and the Pakistani people have no strategic conflict of interest. But with the constant demonization of Pakistan at the hands of US government and its psy-ops managers, every attempt is being made to put the Americans and Pakistanis on a war path, and the ad above is one big step in that direction.
Not all Americans approve of what their government and intelligence are doing. Some of our American friends, including those in Washington, have informed PakNationalists.com that the Web site of Metropolitan Transportation Authority, or MTA, appears to have pulled down the ad in the last couple of hours, but it's still available at other locations.
It's funny how this Mickey-Mouse-clock-and-firecracker 'car bomb' attempt is executed and then a week later a young Pakistani hotel clerk in Chile is arrested with traces of bomb powder on his clothes as he visits the US embassy armed only with visa application documents.
Of course, Pakistan's foreign policy, military, and intelligence communities are not stupid. They know what is going on. But they have orders to ignore this. They are also ignoring the activities of US Embassy in Islamabad as it expands its list of local Pakistani mouthpieces who have been assigned US State Department's new mission of confronting 'anti-Americanism' in Pakistan. The ranks of these US apologists is swelling. They came into action during the last week to desperately try to scuttle any discussion on the fishy circumstances surrounding the terror attempt and focus instead on inducing guilt among Pakistanis and indirectly justify the US pressure to launch new internal wars in Pakistan.
Pakistani government and military is probably ignoring all this, including the provocative language used by Mrs. Clinton in threatening war against Pakistan, in order to avoid a direct confrontation with US or maybe more realistically to ensure the flow of US aid dollars that feed corruption at various levels of Pakistan's power structure.
IMPORTANT NOTE:
This picture invited a lot of feedback in the shortest span of time. It is also doctored. Here it is, above, as it appears on a US-based satirical website with the link. It also appears at several other places, all of them US-based websites. I am emphasizing this to answer some readers who accused our team of doctoring the original MTA ad to spread hatred. Interestingly, US apologists in Pakistan, who are closely linked to the US embassy in Islamabad and US consulates in other cities, conveniently ignore how this kind of insulting anti-Pakistan material is common in the US, actively encouraged by people close to the US government.
The point is the mindset behind this picture. Although the word 'Pakistani' is added by private US citizens, the racial profiling is quite clear on the part of MTA in the choice of the gentleman who appears in the picture. The fact that this doctored image with the word 'Pakistani' is circulating on US websites is a matter of concern and is in bad taste to say the least and does not reflect well on our American friends, most of whom are great people, just as Pakistanis are. Despite all the legitimate criticism in Pakistan on US government policies, never do US critics in Pakistan create and circulate such insulting material to humiliate US citizens as is the case here with this image insulting Pakistanis.
The story above accompanying the image explains how the US government and its pys-ops experts have been busy demonizing Pakistan for political reasons, and how Pakistan's decision makers continue to avoid addressing this manifest anti-Pakistanism on the part of some US government officials and US media. I stand by this argument.
This work by PakNationalists is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Works 3.0 Unported License.
Where did you obtain this advertisement from? I do not think the US has this advert since it goes against any human rights in that contry. Also, if it existed, CNN would be all over it.
ReplyDeleteIf your intention in life is to spread hate, your doing a good job of it, shame on you.
Here's a US-based website where it is posted:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.thecleverest.com/if_you_see.jpg
Here is the original location, NYS's Metropolitan Transportation Authority where the poster has been removed for some unknown reason. Click http://www.mta.info/mta/news/newsroom/images/high-res/seesomething_hi.jpg
Here's a cache image that the Internet preserves. You can see the red line that mentiones 'Pakistani' althoug its not very clear:
http://images.google.com.pk/imgres?imgurl=http://www.mta.info/mta/news/newsroom/images/high-res/seesomething_hi.jpg&imgrefurl=http://adsoftheworld.com/media/print/www_hiddenviolence_nl_chair%3Fsize%3D_original&usg=__mo1kiQASX1XRlG4TxkQuaAsLYsc=&h=832&w=792&sz=129&hl=en&start=2&itbs=1&tbnid=g2IOxrX04B7ZTM:&tbnh=144&tbnw=137&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dmta%2Bnew%2Bad%26hl%3Den%26rlz%3D1T4GGLL_enPK354PK354%26tbs%3Disch:1
From PAUL WOLF on Facebook, commenting on this ad:
ReplyDeleteThe stereotype of Pakistani as terrorist is one which is constantly reinforced in the US media. There are also continuous accusations by US officials that the Pakistani govt secretly supports al Qaeda, the Afghan resistance, etc. Look at what Hillary Clinton just said - there will be serious consequences (read: military) if Pakistan can be blamed. ... See MoreIf that NYC attack had been successful, I'm pretty sure the US would have taken it out on Pakistan, regardless of any real connection. This is what happened to Afghanistan, which is still being punished for attacks planned in Germany by a group of Saudis. I don't understand why Pakistanis let themselves be put in this position instead of demanding respect from a country that claims to be their ally.
Ali,
ReplyDeleteWhy should I be ashamed of it? It is still posted at a US-based news site run by Americans and not Pakistanis. They should be ashamed of it.
http://www.thecleverest.com/if_you_see.jpg
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteAli, even if it's not from NYC, it's still something that is out there and spreading anti-Pakistanism in America. Remember what happened to Japanese-Americans in WWII with this sort of thing?
ReplyDeleteCan't help but remember and laugh at that Indian poster with a in-uniform picture of Air Marshal Tanvir Ahmed. Now that's a mistake that should cause some shame to those who distributed it. :P
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteIt is most definitely not by the "NYC GOVERNMENT!" I have seen this ad many times. It says in red: "Be suspicious of anything unattended."
ReplyDeleteIt may be from a "US-based website" which promotes hatred... don't make a big deal out of actions of ignorant people! You should know better than that!
@Mehjabeen:
ReplyDeleteThis ad is definitely published by the NYC govt. This has been confirmed. Of course, you can see the racial profiling there. Also, the doctored ad with the slur against Pakistanis is also circulating in US websites. You don't see such thing happening in Pakistan. We criticize US policies but never humiliate ordinary Americans.
Note To Everyone:
ReplyDeleteThis picture has invited a lot of feedback in the shortest span of time. It also might be doctored. Here it is, above, as it appears on a US-based news/satire website with the link. It also appears at several other places, all of them US-based websites. So it has not been doctored in Pakistan to spread hatred, as some of the US apologists contended in their emails to us.
I apologize for posting it wihtout further checking the authenticity of the picture. The original ad at NYC's MTA website has been removed. So the authenticity couldn't be immediately checked. We had to rely on Internet cache for comparison which proved inaccurate.
The point is the mindset behind this picture. Although the word 'Pakistani' might be doctored, the racial profiling is quite clear on the part of MTA in the choice of the gentleman who appears in the picture. The fact that this doctored image with the word 'Pakistani' is circulating on US websites is a matter of concern and is in bad taste to say the least and does not reflect well on our American friends, most of whom are great people, just as Pakistanis are. Despite all the legitimate criticism in Pakistan on US Government's policies, never do US critics in Pakistan create and circulate such doctored material to humiliate US citizens as is the case here with this doctored image insulting Pakistanis and posted on US-based websites.
The story that accompanied the image exmplains how the US government and its pys-ops experts have been busy demonizing Pakistan for political reasons, and how Pakistan's decision makers continue to avoid addressing this manifest anti-Pakistanism on the part of some US government officials and US media. And we stand by that argument.
We stand by the rest of the story and conclusions.
AQ
Existing Picture link: http://www.thecleverest.com/if_you_see.jpg
Original NYC MTA link for the picture: http://www.mta.info/mta/news/newsroom/images/high-res/seesomething_hi.jpg
The ad is interesting and so are the comments slamming the post. Glad that all Pakistanis do fall for whatever AQ dishes out.
ReplyDeleteNo one is ignoring this mix of threats and encouragement; it is quite evident that our people have been involved in such activities, but if they are proven innocent then they should be released.
ReplyDeleteshame on all who thinks AQ is wrong and blind folded towards the mass murder in Iraq , Afghanistan and Norther Areas (Pakistan) by US without any proof.
ReplyDeleteBtw are u stupid enough to see the grim picture in Palestine by Israel is it doctored as well.
Also don't forget wat India done in Gujarat and Kashmir.
Open your eyes fellas.
AQ good Job keep it up
Well AQ, thanks for sharing this bullshitting propaganda with us....you are doing a good job and I feel sympathies for so called ultra liberal or apologists. they think that we are buffaloes and following you blindfold. don't have brains to understand what is wrong or right.
ReplyDeleteAnyone can make a website and post any hate material. You can check Mr. ZH’s website also. There isn’t any point to start a debate over it. I have seen 1000 websites which make fun of their own President and religion. I haven’t read literature against it. Stop indulging people into hatred for each other.
ReplyDeleteGeorge E Pataki was NY governor 3 years ago! Do you need any other proof that this ad is doctored? You should have checked it before writing this crap.
ReplyDeleteTerror ploys such as that of Times Square’s cannot effect the cordial relations between U.S and Pakistan; such incidents will bring the two countries closer for a greater degree of cooperation. Terrorism is a global threat and solutions for countering this menace also need to be global.
ReplyDelete@ Ammar,
ReplyDeleteWhat is that, a statement from the Pakistan Foreign Office? Or maybe from the Ambassador's office at our embassy in Washington?
I mean, 'Terrorism is a global threat and solutions for countering this menace also need to be global!'
What horseshit!
Are you working for the pro-American Zardari gov.'s Media Cell, man? You sure look like.
"Terrorim" was invented by the United States military and CIA in the 20th century. It never existed before. It's not a 'global' problem. It's a problem for US private defense contractors, for Raytheon, DynCorp, Xe, and other companies where retirned US intelligence and military officers work.
It's also a problem for MQM, PPPP and ANP, the three pro-US parties ruling Pakistan today.
Get a life and start thinking for yourself.
Need more? Get a life and start using your brain for a change.
.
ReplyDeleteBoycott Pepsi & Coke
Boycott Pepsi & Coke
-
Micky Mouse America
_
www.MickyMouseAmerica.wordpress.com
-
Why dont we boycott everything belonging to Micky Mouse America, i.e. Pepsi & Coke and all other items ??
Why do always complain against Micky Mouse America while shamelessly using its products ?
We all need to spread the message all over the Islamic world that we hate Micky Mouse America and in order to express this hatred, we should boycott all the consumer items of Micky Mouse America particularly Pepsi & Coke.
I am so sick of these stupid apologists and liberals out there who are incapable of putting two and two together and opening their eyes to what is happening.
ReplyDeletemaybe someone should send them to Gitmo and show them how much America loves muslims or would they prefer a cell next to aafia siddiqui since they think this is all a figment of someone’s imagination.instead of looking at this as an article that creates awareness you would rather be deaf dumb and blind.fabulous.fake or not fake this ad is circulating on the net and American Pakistanis don’t like it.but obviously why would liberal puppydogs of America like a lot of people who have written on this page care:their loyalty is somewhere else.
below is an extract from an article that is about life post the Times Square bombing for Pakistanis in the area.Note what it says about the ad and the discrimination/humiliation they are now enduring as a result of the so called Times Square bomb attempt.
“Kiani cited a graphic making the rounds on the Internet, featuring a South Asian man sitting on a New York subway, with a caption reading: ‘If You See Something, Say Something. Even if You’re Pretty Sure He’s Just a Pakistani’.
‘We don’t want Pakistanis to be singled out’,’ Kiani said.
‘They should be seen as very much a part of this society. That’s why they moved here. These false things on the Internet leave a very bad feeling”
the link to the complete article is below and explains what pakistanis have to endure these days.
The point in question IS the mindset as AQ put it.we can scream out,cry out our innocence,protest,give proof but they will still indulge in this BS.that is THEIR mindset,prejudice and paranoia.
Dale E Turner said”We are born with our eyes closed and our mouths open and we spend our whole lives trying to reverse that mistake of nature”
For the love of this country: OPEN YOUR EYES.
Pakistani-Americans facing challenge of being singled
Published: May 16, 2010
http://www.nation.com.pk/pakistan-news-newspaper-daily-english-online/International/16-May-2010/PakistaniAmericans-facing-challenge-of-being-singled/
@zayna
ReplyDeleteWhen it comes to human rights,respect,freedom it is not for us it is only for Americans.we are U-Grade citizens these days.CNN will never telecast news that is in our favour.that is their policy.did you know that the swiss man of a leading opposition party who was the most vociferous in not allowing muslims to build minarets in Europe has converted to islam after thoroughly studying the religion?i didn’t see it on CNN.you wont either.EVER.
did you know that Anne Patterson the US Ambassador,miss-holier-than-thou who is the paragon of human rights,freedom of speech and all that hypocritical BS they sell about America resorted to threats and whatnot in an attempt to shut up US critics on TV,print?THIS is one of her greater feats,do enjoy Americas belief in freedom of expression.Have a teaparty in her honourwhy don’t you-CNN will cover THAT but not THIS:
http://www.daily.pk/news-break-anne-patterson-blocks-shireen-mazari-10053/e Patterson
do you know that a blogger called Pamela Geller has launched ads on a public bus service urging people to leave the “falsity of islam?”.what does that say about what they think about us?go to this site and read what people have to say about this article and how much they respect muslims.this is the article below:
Detroit's SMART bus system has rejected the button-pushing placards that read "Fatwa on your head? Is your community or family threatening you? Leaving Islam?" - and direct Muslims to a Web site urging them to leave the "falsity of Islam."
"It's a purely anti-Muslim hate issue," Dawud Walid of the Council on American-Islamic Relations told the Detroit News on Friday.
"The SMART bus company, or any bus company, should not be used to marginalize a minority group."
Defenders of the ads, dreamed up by Manhattan-based right wing blogger Pamela Geller and the New York-based Stop the Islamization of America, say it's a free speech issue and they have sued.
"Americans have a right to know the truth; Islam is a religion of intolerance and violence," said Michigan lawyer Richard Thompson, who filed the suit.
"Christians, Jews and other non-Muslim minorities are persecuted in every country where Islam dominates."
The MTA has not tried to remove the 40 ads, which Geller said cost her group $10,000 for a one-month run, because they do not violate agency advertising guidelines.
In April, the Miami bus system at first rejected the ads but relented when Geller's group threatened to sue.
A leader in the fight against the proposed mosque near Ground Zero who has Tea Party ties, Geller has been branded a bigot by CAIR and other groups.
She also caused a stir in the right-wing blogosphere by videotaping a denunciation of Palestinian terrorists - while dressed in a bikini.
In an interview with The Daily News, Geller said she didn't care if Muslims were offended by the ads. "Will it bother Islamic supremacists? Yes," she said.
Read more: http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/2010/05/28/2010-05-28_detroit_bus_system_rejects_leaving_islam_ads_as_pure_antimuslim_hate.html#ixzz0pifjaozX
f us?
All the Americans have double standards as recently published in Washington Post. To read about this story, go to: http://fmeducation.blogspot.com/2010/06/who-are-better-hypocrites-muslims-or.html
ReplyDeleteMr. Ahmad Qureshi,
ReplyDeleteSalam alaykum and Ramadan mubarak ho.
I realize that this post is outdated and all that wanted to comment have done so, and the matter is laid to rest.
I had received this "ad" in an email a few months ago and I wrote to the MTA to check the authenticity and, as expected, the picture was a 'mock up'. If I recall correctly, the origin of the post was about two years old and had been posted by some "creative advertising" person.
Anyway, I have read some of the material that comes out from you and wish to state for your consideration that your "hate" may attract following, but you are contributing negatively to this world and to the Muslim ummah by your approach.
I do not spend time surfing so I will appreciate your writing to me on sohail119@gmail.com if you wish to respond.
With best wishes,
Sohail Hameed Khan
Dear Mr. Sohail Hameed Khan,
ReplyDeleteSo it is ok if Americans spread hate against Pakistan and Pakistanis on their websites but if i respond and point out that Americans are spreading anti-Pakistanis, I am accused of spreading hate by you?
If you are an apologetic person and suffer from a doormat personality, that is not my problem.
But I am disturbed when reasonable people like you see me as 'spreading hate' but when several American websites, owned by Ameircan citizens, spread this doctored picture and add 'Pakistani' to it, that's not hate in your eyes?
Please understand that until now, there is not A SINGLE PAKISTANI WEBSITE that spreads hate against or attacks individual American citizens. We limit ourselvs to differing with official US policies. We never disparage ordinary Americans because we have no problem or quarrel with them.
But here you have American citizens and American websites spreading hate against ordinary Pakistanis. But of course you can't see that because you are programmed to see hate only coming from us since, in your eyes, we are the bad guys, we are the ones who spread hate.
I hope you will have the courage to say that when ordinary Americans doctor this picture and add the word 'Pakistani' to it and then use it on their websites, then this is spreading hate against Pakistan and Pakistanis.
Also, the original ad used by MTA four years ago was also racist. The boy they used in the picture, which was all over NYC subway, showed a colored boy who resembled an Arab or a Pakistani more than anyone else.
This is not spreading hate. I am highlighting how anti-Pakistanism is being spread by Americans and it needs to stop. I am asking ordinary Americans, US media and commentators to stop spreading hatred against Pakistan and Pakistanis.